Category Archives: Chinese Head Tax issues + Gim Wong's Ride for Redress

Chinese Head Tax: Jack Layton and Ujjal Dosanjh to mark anniversary of turnaround moment

Chinese Head Tax: Jack Layton and Ujjal Dosanjh to 
mark anniversary of
turnaround moment


Here's the latest from the Head Tax Families Society planning the anniversary of last year's
pivotal moment when Head Tax Redress became an important election issue for the 2006
Federal election. Here's my article from last year's important event:
Chinese Head Tax: Protest in Vancouver Chinatown

Media Advisory: For Immediate Release - November 24, 2006

New Democrat and Liberal MP's to Mark Redress with Head Tax Families:
Jack Layton and Ujjal Dosanjh to Observe Seminal Redress Turnaround
Moment

Vancouver BC - The Head Tax Families Society of Canada (HTFSC) is
encouraged Jack Layton, Leader of the federal New Democrats, and Ujjal
Dosanjh, former Liberal cabinet minister and B. C. premier, will
observe the turnaround of the Chinese head tax/exclusion redress
struggle at a public forum. Invitees included the Leaders and Greater
Vancouver Members of Parliament of the four parties represented in the
House of Commons, the Leaders of parties and Members of the B. C.'s
legislature and elected officials from the three parties represented
at Vancouver city council.

When: 11:00am Saturday, November 25, 2006
Where: Chinese Cultural Center - Dr. David Lam Hall
50 East Pender Street, Vancouver

On November 26 last year, the ad hoc B. C. Coalition of Head Tax
Payers, Spouses and Descendants (BC Coalition) organised a march in
Chinatown to protest the then Liberal government's "no apology, no
compensation" agreement. An information line was set up outside a
closed redress conference funded by the government at the Chinese
Cultural Center and a photo opportunity for Prime Minister Paul Martin
at United Chinese Community Enrichment Social Services (SUCCESS). This
action is considered a seminal moment in the redress struggle.

Several days later, the action manifested itself politically. Kanman
Wong and Darrell Reid, who were at the information line and subsequent
Conservative candidates in the 2006 federal election, joined
Conservative John Cummins MP (Delta-Richmond East) to break with the
party position. On December 8, 2005, with the federal election
underway, Conservative leader Stephen Harper promised action on
Chinese head tax/exclusion redress if elected.

The unilateral settlement imposed by the Government will directly
address only 0.6% of affected head tax families. Approximately 600
surviving head tax payers and spouses will receive $20,000 in ex
gratia payments. Over 82,000 Chinese families paid the unjust tax
between 1885 and 1923 in Canada and 1906 to 1949 in Newfoundland
before joining Confederation.

Members of the BC Coalition formed the Head Tax Families Society of
Canada, a B. C. registered Society with a mandate from over 2,500
written claims for justice and honour for Chinese pioneer families. An
open membership and democratic Society, HTFSC continues its mission
of meaningful redress for head tax families.

-30-

Globe & Mail: “Head-tax Hip Hop” features Trevor Chan in Toronto

Globe & Mail: “Head-tax Hip Hop” features Trevor Chan and No Luck Club in Toronto Head-tax hip hop

Trevor Chan and the No Luck Club created a hip hop / mash up, titled “Our Story” that
addresses the head tax issue, using actual historic sound bites that
were racist descriptions about keeping Canada “White” and about the
threat of the “Yellow Peril.”  It is the 2006 equivalent version
of a protest song.

Earlier this year on January 14, I wrote about their musical/oratoria montage: “Our Story” head tax sound bites and turn table hip hop by No Luck Club

Now the Globe & Mail is writing about them, as they invade Toronto,
bringing the head tax issue to the ears of Toronto's hip hop and just
plain head tax hip culture.


Head-Tax Hip Hop
Special to the Globe and Mail

November 3, 2006

'We don't want Chinamen in Canada. This is a white man's country and white men will keep it so." The speaker's voice, sampled from our not-so-distant past, is but one of many shocking historic sound bites that Vancouver instrumental hip-hop trio No Luck Club spread throughout the cinematic beatscape of Our Story on their just-released album Prosperity.

Using found sound from old educational records and documentaries, No Luck Club's founding brothers Matt and Trevor Chan assembled a politicized "head-tax mash-up" about Canada's former anti-Chinese immigration policies.

"It's us. It's what we're about. It's our history. No one talks about it, but it happened," Trevor Chan explains. "[Our parents] have got their heads down -- they're just working, working, working. But we grew up in a multicultural society, so we're of the mind that you have to say something. What the hell? We're the only race this has happened to."

The Chan family was personally affected by the Chinese head tax and subsequent Exclusion Act. Beginning in 1885 -- after the completion of the railway, of course -- about 82,000 Chinese immigrants were charged up to $500, roughly two years wages, to enter Canada. Then, from 1923 to 1947, the government banned Chinese immigration altogether.

"Our family was separated by the Exclusion Act. Our great-grandfather was to come over and then bring his wife and kids, but you weren't allowed to bring your spouse over for decades," Chan says.

He notes that his parents didn't really "get" their hip-hop take on the topic: "They said "Oh, that's kind of interesting.' But what they did get was the press that surrounded it -- we actually had a lot of coverage in the Chinese media."

Head-tax redress has been a hot-button issue, especially in Vancouver, after two decades of protests finally earned an apology from Prime Minister Stephen Harper during the summer. The first three $20,000 compensation cheques went out on Oct. 20, but with the "symbolic" payments available only to the estimated 400 survivors and widows, rather than their descendants, the redress campaign continues.

When not providing the soundtrack for petition-signing parties, the Chan brothers and third member Paul Belen, a champion turntablist also known as DJ Pluskratch, have been struggling to get their music careers off the ground after their band name proved too apt.

While in high school back in 1989, the Chan brothers started their still-going-strong hip-hop radio show Straight No Chaser on Simon Fraser University's CJSF FM. Inspired by the cut 'n' paste sound collages of artists such as Coldcut and DJ Shadow, they eventually started recording their own music with Matt providing turntable cuts and scratches and Trevor working the laptop beats and samples. In 2000, they sent a demo to 75Ark, a well-respected American indie hip-hop label run by Dan (The Automator) Nakamura, best known for producing the first Gorillaz record.

"They got back to us a week later and said, 'Let's do something,' " Chan recalls. After signing a three-album contract, the brothers began working on a planned trilogy loosely based around the Chinese deities of good fortune.

But their luck proved fleeting when 75Ark folded the following year, just before their debut Happiness was set to drop. They found a new home with Ill Boogie Records, but soon after No Luck Club's first album finally came out in the fall of 2003, that label also closed its doors.

After adding DJ Paul Belen to their lineup in 2004, they got back to work on a follow-up album. But after so many label snafus, they decided to release Prosperity independently, although "it was a decision we made kicking and screaming, my friend."

This scratch-laden and beat-based sophomore opus further advances their virtuosic widescreen sound, bolstering their already eclectic retinue of jazz, funk, techno, classical and spy soundtrack samples with new Bollywood and Latin flavours.

Speaking of widening their geographic scope, the night after No Luck Club's CD release party at Toronto's Supermarket on Nov. 8, the trio will appear at the Rivoli to perform a world music show originally commissioned for the Vancouver Folk Festival.

"They probably thought we were going to take old folk records, throw on a drumbeat and start scratching over top," Chan says. "But we thought, 'Let's take our collage approach and expand it.' Usually we draw from funk and rock and electronic music, so we apply the same methods but take percussion from North Africa, combined with Indonesian gamelan music and throw in some Indian string instruments.
You create this crazy mess."

But though their album revels in Chinese culture through political sound bites and kung fu samples -- "people who watch Hong Kong films and know Cantonese might recognize some and be like, 'Oh my God, that's so badass' -- there's no Chinese instrumentation to be heard.

"This is something I really want to do, but I don't want to mess it up," Chan says. "Our grandfather and uncles do play traditional Chinese instruments so we did grow up listening to that. But I want to improve my production chops so that when we do create music using those elements, we're doing it a service rather than taking away from it," he says.

"We've got to represent."

No Luck Club plays a CD release party Nov. 8, 9 p.m., $6. Supermarket 268 Augusta Ave., 416-840-0501. The group plays a CBC Radio 3 taping Nov. 9, 8:30 p.m., $6. The Rivoli, 334 Queen St. W., 416-596-1908.


Head Tax Compilation video on Shaw Cable: Watch EarthSeen

Head Tax Compilation video on Shaw Cable: Watch EarthSeen

Sid Tan has put together a compilation video with a “head tax” theme for the “Earth Seen” time slot on Shaw cable 4.  It's a one hour show.  Set your video machine!

EarthSeen: Head Tax Compilation

Wednesday, November 1 @ 8-9pm
Saturday, November 4 @ 3-4am
Saturday, November 11 @ 3-4am
Sunday, November 12 @ 4-5pm

1) Our Story: Chinese Head Tax Mash Up music video by no luck club (NLC). Very impressive presentation with profound message from youths” .to the world.

2) Gim Wong music video with words and music by Sean Gunn performed by the Running Dog lackeys. Celebrates Gim Wong's cross Canada motorcycle Ride for Redress in 2005.

3) A Paper Son by producer Gein Wong. A video from the Re/Present series of the Chinese Canadian Nation Council youth online project in 2005.

3) November 26, 2005 information line at closed redress conference at Chinese Cultural Centre and subsequent phto-op of then Prime Minister Paul Martin to SUCCESS.

4) Karen Cho's highlights of June 22, 2005 apology in Ottawa by Prime Minister Stephen Harper/Govn of Canada. Karen is director of In the Shadow of Gold Mountain.

(5) Head Tax Blues music video with words and music by Sean Gunn and performed by Sean Gunn and Ula Shine. Excepts of the this video have been on nation televison three times and also in Karen Cho's ITSOGM.

6) Mouseland (1992) animated short of speech by Tommy Douglas, founding leader of the CCF (later became the New Democratic Party). Introduction by Keifer Sutherland, Tommy Douglas's grandson.


ACCESS community television on Shaw cable 4, the cable community channel in Greater Vancouver and Fraser Valley.

Saltwater City Television and EarthSeen are regularly scheduled volunteer-produced community television programs produced by the not-for-profits ACCESS Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality and Solidarity Society with assistance from ICTV Independent Community Television Co-operative.

Thanks to Community Media Education Society (CMES), the Chinese Canadian National Council (CCNC), the National Anti-Racism Council of Canada (NARCC) and the Status Through Action Towards Unity and Solidarity (STATUS) Coalition for their human and morale resources.

Please do not ask me for copies unless you can pay for or barter an hour of time. We do this so people can record our programs off-the-air. If you don't have cable, ask a friend. No friends with cable becomes a special situation if you really need copy. Better yet, join us and you can make all the copies you want and even produce some television.

Take care.    anon    Sid.

Redress: One Voice and More Strength Now…

Redress: One Voice and More Strength Now…


Sid Tan (in green) stands with leading head tax redress campaigners Victor Wong (CCNC executive director) and Gim Wong (WW2 veteran who rode his motorcycle from Victoria to Ottawa to raise awareness).  Sitting are Thomas Soon and Charlie Quan holding the 1st and 2nd cheques presented by Ottawa to surviving head tax payers – photo Todd Wong

Here's a letter from my friend Sid Tan, that summarizes the present state of the head tax redress campaign – after the successful presentation of the first payment cheque to Charlie Quan on Friday October, 20th.  Sid has been active on the head tax redress campaign since the 1980's.

Yo All.

Our struggle has just weathered the first of federal government's public relations and media opportunities well. There will be the spouses' payment and then the community fund government blitz and photo-ops. Already the boys at Quan Lung Sai Tong are reporting talk of compliant individuals floating positions asking for the return of symbolic $500. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but I find such sentiments self-serving and seeking to curry favour with the government. It hurts our cause. The federal government has already set the financial bar at $20,000 and our basic principle is that all head tax families be treated equally. One certificate, one claim.

In our call for a just and honourable redress, there must be the respect and dignity of good faith negotiations with representatives of head tax families. Redress seeking groups must have non-competing positions. All must call for a full measure of justice and honour. Anything less for head tax families would forever reduce our community to one of undeserving or unable, forever discriminated, forever with less than equal rights. Our children and their children, our future generations will suffer our failure in political participation.

The Government of Canada is providing about 0.6% of head tax families those with surviving payers and spouses – with direct redress. Not all the remaining 99.4% of the families will be seeking direct redress. Indeed, some of these families may even oppose the call for direct redress. This is to be expected. We must be bold and clear about our demands. For me personally, they are quite straightforward:

1) the Government of Canada must recognize and acknowledge redress is incomplete;
2) the Government of Canada must commit to good faith negotiationswith representatives of head tax families seeking direct redress; and
3) the Government of Canada must act in the spirit as articulated in the Quan Manifesto of March 22, 2006.

The Head Tax Families Society of Canada, successor to the BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants, has now been incorporated under the BC Societies Act. Our small merry band has carried the struggle well the past year. Our numbers increase and we grow stronger by the day. We ask people across the country to sign onto our petition and help get signatures as well. The November 25 (starts 11:00am) Outside Inside event at the Chinese Cultural Centre to observe a year of struggle will be a membership drive kick-off.

ACCESS Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality and Solidarity Society continues to support and will move forward the Quan Manifesto,  reducing the $35,000 refund to $20,000 as the government gave to surviving head tax payers and spouses in ex gratia payments. ACCESS will soon be asking the BC Ombudsman to investigate whether the BC government is intransigent and dismissive of requests to be
forthcoming in regards to its unjust enrichment of an estimated $9-million in head taxes received from 1903 to 1923.

Given how far we have come and how hard we are working, we can look forward to raising the incomplete redress in the upcoming federal and provincial election. The struggle still continues.

Take care.    Anon    Sid

PS  Following is an email sent to Minister Oda and Secretary Kenney with Quan Manifesto and the ACCESS position then.

May 8, 2006

Hon. Bev Oda
Minister of Canadian Heritage & Status of Women

Mr. Jason Kenney, MP
Parliamentary Secretary to the Prime Minister

Dear Minister Oda and Mr. Kenney,

Thank you for your continuing efforts to reach a just and honourable settlement for the Chinese head-tax and exclusion redress. On behalf of ACCESS Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality and Solidarity Society, I have the pleasure to support the proposal of Charlie Quan Song Now, a 98-year old head-tax payer and inspiring champion for a significant and meaningful redress. You may recall I passed you his handwritten proposal during the morning session of the March 24, 2006 consultation at George Brown House in Toronto.

What I call the Quan Manifesto is a simple, respectful and dignified approach to an appropriate redress. It will cost close to the approximate $425-million of the 1988 Japanese Canadian redress. With a financial cap of $450-million, it is actually less given the inflation factor. The Quan Manifesto assumes all claimant head-tax payer families have legal successors and eligible estates. It assumes all members of the family, the basic unit of Chinese and most civilisations, suffered hardship due to the head-tax and endured the separation of exclusion.

The Quan Manifesto
1) One certificate, one payment.
2) Payment to:
     a) Head-tax payer
     b) Spouse if deceased head-tax payer.
     c) Equally to children or in-laws. If no children
         to in-laws in place of sons or daughters.
     d) $35,000 tax free
      e) Apology to above in order
(signed)
Charlie Quan Song Now, Foon Chang, Sidney Tan
March 22, 2006  Saltwater City (Vancouver, BC)

In our estimation, there are approximately 4,000 claimant head-tax payer families. The $450-million cap will allow for a $35,000 payment to 12,000 claimant head-tax payer families. In the Japanese Canadian redress, individual payments of $21,000 to claimants were approximately 3.5 times the initial number of claimants. Should the number of claimants be less than 12,000, the remainder would be added to the community fund. If the number of claimants exceeds 12,000, there would be a proportional decrease of the $35,000 payment to include all. Note there is a $30-million cushion as 12,000 times $35,000 is only $420-million.

As added value to the Quan Manifesto, we ask that 82,369 Canadian legal tender $1,000 Gold Mountain dollars, in gold alloy of course, be added to Canada's numismatic history. The initial $1000 payment to each head-tax payer claimant family would be a Gold Mountain dollar. Over $82-million from the $450-million cap would be required but if need be, some claimant head-tax payer families maybe required to accept more than one Gold Mountain dollar. Indeed, these Gold Mountain dollars may even fetch a premium which could be added to the $450-million cap.

The Quan Manifesto simply asks the government to pay back what we believe to be a fair, acceptable and symbolic amount to claimant head-tax families which is significant and meaningful. Clearly head-tax/exclusion money should go to those directly affected. The acknowledgment, commemoration and education community projects should be funded from existing programs within Canadian Heritage and other government departments and not funds directed to redress claimant head-tax families.

You should know Charlie Quan has thought long and hard about his proposal. It has the legitimacy of being made by a head-tax payer.  Note he wants all claimants to be treated equally with his “one certificate, one payment” principle. In doing so, he removes himself from the front of the line to stand with the others to receive what they receive. Mr. Quan asked me to deliver his proposal, after Foon Chang and I signed it, to you for consideration when I told him about my invitation to the March 24 consultation. You now have his handwritten proposal, which may very well turn out to be a historical document.

ACCESS, successor to Vancouver Association of Chinese Canadians (VACC), is a not-for-profit anti-racism, human rights and social justice society as well as a community television corporation. It is an affiliate of the Chinese Canadian National Council and a member of the National Anti-Racism Council of Canada and STATUS Coalition. ACCESS works with other equality seeking organizations to fight racism and discrimination, to advance the rights of citizens and migrants living in Canada and to press the federal government to redress the Chinese head-tax/exclusion.

We are willing to work with you and your government to resolve this injustice. Good faith negotiations within an open and transparent process for resolution will determine the success or failure in reaching a just and honourable settlement. We propose the $450-million financial cap because neither you nor your government has proposed one. We do understand consensus is not everyone in our community will agree with us, but that they may disagree with us but will not block or hinder us.

We would be pleased to receive comments from you regarding our proposal. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Yours truly,
Sid Chow Tan, President
ACCESS Association of Chinese Canadians
For Equality and Solidarity Society

4040 Inverness Street
Vancouver, BC   V5V 4W5

Cc.: Victor Wong, CCNC
        Karin Lee, BC Coalition
        Harvey Lee, BC Coalition
        George Jung, BC Coalition
        Libby Davies MP, Vancouver East
        David Emerson MP, Vancouver Kingsway
        Ujjal Dosanjh MP, Vancouver South

Globe & Mail: Final Hopes realized at last – redress + correction

Globe & Mail: Final Hopes realized at last – redress
+ correction

Here is the Petti Fong article in the Globe & Mail.  It was nice to meet Petti at the ceremony.
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20061021.BCHEADTAX21/TPStory//BritishColumbia/

Victor Wong, executive director of the Chinese Canadian National Council, sends this correction for the article:

Just a small
correction to the Globe article (the BC version has a more extensive
story than the national version online). We met Charlie when he showed
up at one of our community meetings when the lawsuit was launched (not
in mid 80s). First Sid, then Gim and I developed a friendship with him
as  he was the only surviving HT payer  attending and we  promised  him
that we would  fight to get his money back for him.  Some of you may
have read Sid's account of helping Charlie back in August with his
application, and there are clips of Gim and Charlie in Karen Cho's
documentary (Gim: “I made a promise to Charlie….”). The 'story within
a story' concluded yesterday when Minister Bev Oda called upon Charlie
Quan to receive the first ex-gratia payment of $20,000. Gim Wong,
resplendent in uniform, sat beside Charlie and the presentation
ceremony was held up for a few moments when harlie sat back down in his
seat as Charlie and Gim counted the zeroes on the cheque.


We did keep our promise to Charlie Quan, all of us did.


cheers,
Victor

Final hopes realized at last — redress

Ottawa hands out cheques in Chinatown to three who had to pay infamous head tax

VANCOUVER
— Their combined ages round off to 200, and with all their years lived
and all their dreams fulfilled or forgotten, Charlie Quan and Thomas
Soon each had just one hope left.

The two men wanted to live long enough to see the government
apologize and repay them for the $500 head tax it cost each of them to
enter Canada.

They arrived separately as teenagers and they lived very different
lives. But when Mr. Soon, 97, arrived inside the meeting hall yesterday
and saw Mr. Quan, 99, the two elderly men reached toward each other,
grasped the other's hands and held on as if they were old friends.

“It feels like we've been waiting for this day for a long time,” Mr.
Soon said after receiving his $20,000 cheque from the federal
government for redress. “For many years, I did not have hope it would
happen. I knew I had to live long enough to see it.”

Last week, while in Vancouver, Prime Minister Stephen Harper said
apologizing to the Chinese community for the head tax was the only
thing the government could do to right the decades-old wrong.

The 1923 Exclusion Act, which divided families after an onerous $500
entry fee was put into effect for people coming from China, was a
“moral blemish on our country's soul,” Mr. Harper said. It was finally
lifted in 1947 at the request of Chinese-Canadian soldiers who fought
in the Second World War. The government gave in to their demands for
full citizenship rights and lifted the fee.

Mr. Soon arrived in Canada as a 13-year-old, with the weight of his
family's village on his shoulders. Relatives paid his entry fee and he
was put to work to pay the tax back and send money home to his parents
and siblings.

He did it with pennies saved from the $25 he earned each month working at a vegetable and food stand.

“I didn't think about that too much,” Mr. Soon said when asked if
the debt he had to repay overwhelmed him. “I was too busy working and
saving money.”

When repeatedly asked yesterday about what he planned to do with the money from the government, his answers were simple.

“Take it to the bank. Spend it,” said Mr. Soon, handing the cheque over to his wife Siumui Soon.

Canadian Heritage and Status of Women Minister Bev Oda handed out
three cheques yesterday in Vancouver's Chinatown — to Mr. Soon, Mr.
Quan and Betty Jung, daughter-in-law of Ah Foo Chin, who was unable to
attend in person.

Unlike Mr. Quan, who plans to spend some of the money by taking his family to China, Mr. Soon said he's too old to travel now.

“The only plan I have is maybe dinner with the family,” he said yesterday.

When Sid Tan and Victor Wong, two community activists, first met
Charlie Quan in the mid-1980s and learned he was a head-tax payer, they
promised him they would fight for redress.

“We made him that promise and we never forgot,” said Mr. Wong, the executive director of the Chinese Canadian National Council.

“We knew it was going to be a fight.”

When the association began trying to get redress for head-tax
payers, there were still 2,000 to 3,000 of them living in the 1980s.
But today, just 36 surviving payers have been identified.

The government will pay $20,000 to each living head-tax payer and to spouses of deceased head-tax payers.

Chan Suen, 75, wept as she remembered her father who paid the head tax as a young man and died in the 1960s.

“My heart is very black today,” Ms. Chan said in Cantonese as she wiped tears from her eyes at the ceremony.

While she was glad for Mr. Soon and Mr. Quan, she grieved for her family and the hardship her father suffered.

“The government took this first step and I can't understand why they
can't take the second step and help the family of the people who paid.”

Sid Tan's grandparents are dead and both paid the tax. He said there
are about 81,000 descendents the government won't compensate.

“The Harper government is saying the Chinese do not deserve
justice,” said Mr. Tan, who vowed to continue pressing the government
to provide redress for descendents. “We are building a movement that
will outlast the Harper government.”

For Mr. Quan, who came to Canada as a skinny 15-year-old in 1923 and
worked for 20 years in Leader, Sask., to pay off the $500 fee, he says
his satisfaction on the eve of turning 100 is that he outlasted the
government.

“They kept saying for years they weren't going to pay, but I knew
that one day the government would do the right thing,” he said.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/LAC.20061021.BCHEADTAX21/TPStory//BritishColumbia/

Charlie Quan receives the first head tax redress cheque

Charlie Quan receives the first head tax redress cheque


Arms raised in triumph! Head
Tax redress campaigners Victor Wong, Gim Wong, Sid Tan stand behind the
second and first head tax ex-gratia payments to Thomas Soon and Charlie
Quan – photo Todd Wong

Ninety-nine year old Charlie Quan recieved the very first ex-gratia cheque
for Chinese head tax redress, presented by Bev Oda, Minister of
Canadian Heritage and Status of Women.  Oda and David Emerson,
Minister of International Trade and Minister for the Pacifc Gateway and
the Vancouver-Whistler Olympics, were in town to present the cheques to
Quan, Thomas Soon (aged 95) and Ah Foon Chin (aged 96) who could not attend and was represented by his daughter-in-law. 

In 1923, Quan had to
pay $500 to enter Canada, estimated to be the cost of a house or two
years wages back then.  Only ethnic Chinese were charged the head
tax.  It was a concerted effort to keep Canada white, and
discourage Chinese from coming to Canada. 
Beginning in 1885, the Canadian government imposed a
$50 fee on Chinese immigrants, which was raised to $100 in 1900 and to
$500 in 1903. But by 1923,
Chinese were still coming, so the Canadian government passed the
“Chinese Exclusion Act” which effectively banned all Chinese
immigration, and was not rescinded untl 1947, after WW2,

During the head tax redress campaign,
Charlie Quan repeatedly stated that he wanted his money back. 
Quan was interviewed for the NFB documentary ” In the Shadow of Gold Mountain,
” written and directed by head tax descendant Karen Cho. 
Earlier in 2006, Quan stated that he thought a head tax redress
settlement would be worth $35,000. 

After Quan received his cheque and posed for pictures with Minister Bev Oda, he sat down beside his friend Gim Wong,
also a veteran of Chinese head tax who completed a “Ride for Redress” on his motorcycle across
Canada to Ottawa in 2005 to draw attention to the head tax/exclusion act redress
campaign. Wong was also featured in the movie “In the Shadow of Gold Mountain.” 
Quan and Gim immediately looked at the cheque and
began to count to check the number of “zeroes”on it.  After so
many years of seemingly hopeless campagining, they still found it hard
to believe that redress payments were actually happening. 
Payments for surviving spouses will begin in November, 2006.



Hon. Bev Oda presents the cheque to
Thomas Soon in front of media cameras.  Gim Wong (seated 
center in uniform) smiles.  Charlie Quan shows his cheque to
grandson Terry. – photo Todd Wong

Quan was accompanied by his favorite grandson Terry Quan and Terry's
wife and two children.  Together they represented a legacy of four
generations of Chinese Canadians going back to 1923 when Charlie Quan
arrived with his father in 1923.

Also accompanying Quan and Wong, were Victor Wong, executive
director
of the Chinese Canadian National Council,
Colleen Hua (national CCNC
president), and Sid Tan national CCNC board representative.  Both
Wong and Hua and travelled from Toronto to attend the event, and both
say they will continue the campaign to include descendants of
predeceased head tax payers and spouses.



Head Tax redress campaigners Ron Mah,
Colleen Hua (CCNC National president), Gim Wong and Victor Wong (CCNC
executive director) – photo Todd Wong

It was the CCNC that helped lead the campaign for a more comprehensive
redress package than the Agreement-in-Principle that was signed almost
a year ago by Prime Minister Paul Martin.  That agreement gave no
apology nor individual compensation, and only promised an
“acknowledgement,” and community funding.

Also present were many of the members of the Head Tax Families Society,
including Ron Mah, Foon Chan, Cynthia Lee and myself.  Other head
tax descendants attending were Col. Howe Lee and Vancouver city
councillor George Chow.  Howe was a signatory on the Liberal
Agreement-in-principle document for which the veterans signed onto
because they hoped to see some form of “acknowledgement” in their
lifetime as they saw their numbers  dwindling each year.  Up
until the Liberal A.I.P., no previous Canadian government had been
willing to tackle the Chinese head tax or Exclusion Act
issue.   While the NDP, Bloc Quebecois and Green Party each
agreed to the CCNC call for Head Tax apology – the Conservative Party
did not join the redress bandwagon until after Prime Minister Paul
Martin stumbled on his pseudo apology given on a Chinese language radio
program.


Head Tax Descendants: Vancouver City
Councillor George Chow and Col. Howe Lee, president of the Chinese
Canadian Military Museum attended the event – photo Todd Wong.

After the initial and obligatory photographs of each cheque
recipient were taken with Ministers Oda and Emerson, I suggested a
photo with all
the head tax descendants in the room together.  Both Sid Tan and
Howe Lee had to finish media interviews before they were able to join
us standing at the front.  The three head tax redress cheque
recipients sat on chairs in front, beside Ministers Oda and
Emerson.  Gim and Sid were both heard saying to Charlie Quan “We
kept our promise” – which was to continue campaigning for head tax
redress until he would a redress payment.  They cut it pretty darn
close to Charlie turning 100 years old before the redress payment
arrived.

I was asked today how I felt about the presentation of the cheques, and
my reply was that it is bittersweet.  Only less than 1% of 81,000
head tax payers and spouses will recieve the ex-gratia cheque payments,
because the Conservative government is only giving them to surviving
head tax payers or their surviving spouses.  This means that there
will be no recognition of the head tax certificate paid by my
great-grandfather Ernest Lee, because both he and my great-grandmother
passed away a long time ago.  Only head tax payers and spouses who
were still alive in February 2006 when the Conservative government came
to power will be recognized.

Sid Tan, long time head tax activist since the 1980's says that the
campaign for honour and justice will continue.  Sid's late
grandfather paid the head tax, but his grandmother is no longer alive
to collect a redress cheque.

But all is not bitter….  There is much to celebrate.  One
year ago on Novmber 26th.  Then Prime Minister Paul Martin came to
Vancouver for the A-I-P ceremony, and met with Charlie Quan, so that
Martin could have a “face to face”with an actual living breathing head
tax payer. Martin told Quan to his face, that there would be no
individual compensation.  What a difference seven months made when
on June 22, Charlie Quan sat at the Hotel Vancouver listening to Prime
Minister Harper make an apology for the Chinese head tax, and promised
that there would be payments to living head tax payers and spouses.

After the ceremony, we walked up Pender St. and celebrated at the New
Town Bakery for lunch.  Charlie was surrounded by his grandson and
grandsons.  Gim Wong sat at the next table with Ron Chin, Foon
Chang, Victor Wong and myself.  Sid joined us immediately after
going to the CBC studios for an interview.  We took
pictures.  Charlie held his cheque up for all to see. And…
Charlie Quan paid for our celebration.



The celebratory meal…  Charlie
Quan holds his ex-gratia head tax payment cheque, accompanied by
redress campaigners Sid Tan, Gim Wong, Foon Chang, Ron Mah, Victor Wong
and Todd Wong

Click here for Susanna Ng's article + pictures:  Canada-delivers-first-head-tax-redress


Click here for more Head Tax information, links and stories on www.gunghaggisfatchoy.com

check out these other head tax media stories:

Ottawa issues head tax redress payments to Chinese Canadians

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/british-columbia/story/2006/10/20/head-tax.html

Cheques of $20,000 given to surviving head tax payers

CCNC: First Redress Payments Issued On Friday

CCNC:  First Redress Payments Issued On Friday

Here's a news release from the Chinese Canadian National Council in Toronto.

Finally after many years of campaigning, and after many peaceful marches and demonstrations and rallies and meetings… redress payment for the Chinese head tax is happening.  I will be there.

For Immediate Release

October 18, 2006

First Redress Payments Issued On Friday

(Toronto/Vancouver). Representatives of the Chinese Canadian National Council (CCNC) will be attending the presentation of first redress payments to Chinese Head Tax payers in Vancouver on Friday. CCNC representatives include: Colleen Hua, CCNC National President, Sid Chow Tan, CCNC National Director and Victor Wong, CCNC Executive Director.

Where:      S.U.C.C.E.S.S.

            28 West Pender St. , Vancouver , British Columbia

When:       October 20, 2006 at 10:30 am

CCNC and redress groups have led the campaign for redress of the Chinese Head Tax, Newfoundland Head Tax and Chinese Exclusion Act for over 22 years. During this period, CCNC has registered more than 4000 head tax payers and families seeking a just and honourable resolution. On June 22, 2006, Prime Minister Stephen Harper issued a formal apology and announced individual symbolic financial redress to living head tax payers and living spouses of deceased head tax payers.

CCNC and redress groups have been assisting the living head tax payers with their application since late August. “We are very happy for the head tax payers who will be receiving these first payments,” Colleen Hua, CCNC National President said today. “This is a restorative moment for the Chinese Canadian community as we begin a genuine process of reconciliation with the Canadian Government.”

CCNC and redress groups continue to press for redress that is inclusive of all head tax families. “The June 22nd redress announcement covers just over 10% of the head tax families registered with us,” Victor Wong, CCNC Executive Director said today. “We will press for inclusive redress to restore dignity to all head tax families including those where the head tax payer and spouse have both passed away.”

CCNC continues to work with other redress groups including the Ontario Coalition of Chinese Head Tax Payers and Families (Ontario Coalition) and B.C. Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants (B.C. Coalition) in the campaign to redress the Chinese Head Tax and Chinese Exclusion Act.

 

-30-

 

For more information, please contact Victor Wong at (416) 977-9871.

Head tax redress: Outside Inside: Observing A Year of Redress Struggle

Sid Tan sends this media release as the first redress cheques will be 
presented in Vancouver on Friday.

Media Advisory: For Immediate Release - October 19, 2006

Outside Inside: Observing A Year of Redress Struggle:
Seminal Moment "On the Streets" Creates Turnaround

Vancouver BC - The Head Tax Families Society of Canada (HTF),
successor group to the BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and
Descendants (BC Coalition), will observe the turnaround of the Chinese
head tax/exclusion redress struggle with a public forum. Invitees
include Greater Vancouver Members of Parliament from the three parties
represented in the House of Commons, the BC Attorney General and
Minister of Multiculturalism, the three Chinese Canadians sitting on
Vancouver City Council and other elected officials.

When: 11:00am Saturday, November 25, 2006
Where: Chinese Cultural Center - Dr. David Lam Hall
50 East Pender Street, Vancouver

"Outside Inside" refers to last November 26 when several hundred
people set up an information line in Chinatown. It attended outside a
closed redress conference funded by the government at the Chinese
Cultural Center and a photo opportunity for Prime Minister Paul Martin
at United Chinese Community Enrichment Social Services (SUCCESS). This
"on the streets" action is now considered by many in the redress
movement as a seminal moment in the redress struggle.

At the time, governing Liberals were reaching an Agreement in
Principle (AIP) to direct millions of dollars in a community redress
fund to a pro-Beijing group created in the aftermath of Tiananmen
Square in 1989. Then, the opposition Conservatives were introducing
Private Member's Bill C-333 allowing the Liberal government to direct
millions of dollars to the same group, which would accept the funds on
an agreed precondition of "no apology, no compensation" to head tax
families.

The Chinese Canadian National Council (CCNC) and local Association of
Chinese Canadians for Equality and Solidarity Society (ACCESS), who
were against Bill C-333 and AIP, enlisted head tax families and
supporters to make a strong and definitive statement that the
Government's and Official Opposition's actions were a betrayal. The ad
hoc BC Coalition was revived and called for political participation
and peaceful assembly. Recently, the Head Tax Families Society of
Canada was formed to call for good faith negotiations between the
federal government and representatives of head tax families for a just
and honourable redress to all head tax families.

The unilateral settlement imposed by the Government will directly
address only 0.6% of affected head tax families. Approximately 600
surviving head tax payers and spouses will receive $20,000 in ex
gratia payments. Over 82,000 Chinese families paid the unjust tax
between 1885 and 1923 in Canada and 1906 to 1949 in Newfoundland
before joining Confederation.

-30-

Georgia Straight: Head-tax redress fails to account for total toll

Here's a Georgia Straight story
about how the Harper Conservative government falls short on their
promise to provide a redress that is fair to everybody. 

Harvey Lee and I both became active in the Head Tax redress campaign
at the November 25th rally against then Prime Minister Paul Martin's
feeble attempt to provide redress – by no apology, and no individual
compensation or head tax refund.  It was a day that will go down
in Chinese Canadian history, when head tax descendants told the
government that they wanted a fair redress with negotiation, similar to
the Japanese-Canadian 1988 redress.  We did it with placards,
chants and media interviews.  We told our truth.  see
article: 
Chinese Head Tax: Protest in Vancouver Chinatown


The
Conservative's redress package will give $20,000 to surviving head tax
payers and spouses.  But if your father, mother, grandparents, or
great-grandparents died before the Conservatives came to power, then
you are out of luck.  An estimated 81,000 paid the the head tax,
including my grand-father, my great-grandfather and many other family
members. They have all passed on now.  Under the Conservative
program, only and estimated 430 people will recieve a redress
compensation package.  This is 0.6% of the people who paid. 
The Mulroney Conservative government gave $21,000 to each
Japanese-Canadian person born before 1947.

My friend Sid Tan reports that today's
(Oct. 12/06) Sing Tao has Mary Yang's exclusive interview with PM
Harper. In the interview, Harper says “that's it”for head tax/exclusion
redress from his government.   Sid Tan says”

“Harper
has shown political acumen for buying votes but no sense of justice and
honour. Shame on him and his government for taking an issue of justice
and honour and trying to pander for votes. As far as I'm concerned, the
gloves off. Was never good at the touchie-feelie-smilie-schmoozie stuff
and will work to ensure Harper and his government loses or at least
does not acrue any political capital from this incomplete redress.

A
just an honourable redress requires good faith negotiations between the
government and  representatives of head tax families seeking
individual redress and direct refund of head tax.  Our movement is
strong and lasting. We have outlasted the Trudeau, Mulroney, Chretien
and Martin governments. We are growing stronger by the day and will
outlast Harpers's government if a just and honourable redress is not
coming.”


Head-tax redress fails to account for total toll

http://www.straight.com/content.cfm?id=21219

By charlie smith

Publish Date: 12-Oct-2006

Harvey Lee, whose family was forced apart by racist immigration laws, says Stephen Harper’s reparations have come to appear largely political.

Harvey Lee, whose family was forced apart by racist immigration laws,
says Stephen Harper’s reparations have come to appear largely
political.

A
Vancouver man has attributed the death of his mother to the Chinese
head tax. But he won’t be among those receiving federal compensation
because his parents died before Prime Minister Stephen Harper announced
that $20,000 payments will go to surviving head-tax payers and their
spouses.

Harvey Lee, a retiree, told his tale to the Georgia
Straight shortly before attending an October 10 dinner at Floata
restaurant in Chinatown. “There are a lot of descendants who suffered
just as much as their parents did due to the head tax and the exclusion
act,” Lee said. “Myself, I was separated from my family for years. I
was a teenager before I got to see my father.”

At the dinner,
Prime Minister Stephen Harper spoke of his pride about issuing an
apology for the head tax, which he described as “a moral blemish on our
country’s soul”. Harper also emphasized how “especially important and
satisfying” it was to him that his government will make payments to
survivors.

Beginning in 1885, the Canadian government imposed a
$50 fee on Chinese immigrants, which was raised to $100 in 1900 and to
$500 in 1903. Vancouver East NDP MP Libby Davies told Parliament that
this would be the equivalent of about $30,000 in 2005 dollars. In 1923,
the government passed a law, which wasn’t lifted until 1947, banning
almost all Chinese immigration.

Lee said that his father paid
the $500 head tax when he came to Canada in 1910. His mother paid the
$500 fee when she arrived nine years later. He said his mother
eventually took the family back to China because of all the racism in
Canada, and Lee was born in Hong Kong in 1939. His father stayed in
Canada, eventually operating a restaurant in Souris, Manitoba.

When
war broke out in the Far East, the family was separated. Lee said that
his mother could have avoided the hostilities and legally returned to
Canada because she had already paid the head tax. However, Lee said,
she remained in China because she didn’t want to leave him as a little
baby with relatives. Canadian law at the time banned the children of
head-tax payers from entering the country, so Lee wouldn’t have been
permitted into Canada with his mother.

In 1943, Lee said, his
mother was killed by Japanese invaders while she was trying to flee
with her family. He was only four years old at the time. “She
sacrificed her life,” Lee said, wiping a tear from his eye. “She died
because she couldn’t bring me over.”

He then apologized, saying
that he gets emotional every time he tells this story. “My grandmother
brought me up until after the war. Then my dad sent for us, and then my
brother and I came over.”

Lee said he arrived in Canada in 1951
when he was 12 years old. He eventually went on to a career in
management, but expressed regret that he never got to know his father
very well. “We never really bonded,” he said. “That was another problem
with the separation.”

When asked how he feels about Harper’s
handling of the head-tax issue, Lee replied, “Initially, he started
well. He kept his promise of the apology. But the redress has fallen a
little bit short. It’s a little bit more politics there than it is
redress.”

At a demonstration outside the event, Sid Tan,
president of the Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality and
Solidarity, said that only 0.6 percent of head-tax families will be
redressed because the vast majority of head-tax payers and their
spouses died before Harper issued a federal apology last June. “We want
the other 99.4 percent of head-tax families to be redressed,” Tan
shouted.

Moments later, the crowd joined him in a chant, “Head tax, redress, head tax, redress…”

Prime Minister Harper comes to Vancouver Chinatown and announces “Head Tax payments soon” – dialogue with which Chinese-Canadians?

Prime Minister Stephen Harper came to Vancouver Chinatown for a dinner
meeting with Chinese business community.  It was organized by
Jimmy Fong, president of Vancouver's Community Care and Advancement
Association. 

Several ironies appeared.  Harper made the announcement that
payments for Head Tax Compensation would happen soon.  But the two
of the leading organizations responsible for the head tax redress
awareness, ACCESS and Head Tax Families Association, were not invited
to the dinner.

Several community groups staged a protest because: the majority (99%)
of head tax families have been excluded from the redress payments; and
of the “new government's positions on the War in Afghanistan.

As well, as reporter for Ming Pao was battered because he was attacked by a frustrated motorist. 
see: http://chineseinvancouver.blogspot.com/2006/10/reporter-battered.html

Head tax compensation to be paid soon:
Harper

Updated Wed. Oct. 11
2006 11:14 AM ET

CTV.ca News Staff

Ottawa will
begin to redress the head tax once applied to Chinese immigrants with payments
to survivors in the next few weeks, Prime Minister Stephen Harper said.

Speaking
at a dinner hosted by a Chinese immigrant group, Harper said Tuesday it's
important that this happen now while some of those who paid the tax to enter
Canada
are still alive to receive the symbolic $20,000 payments.

Harper
called the tax “a moral blemish on our country's soul.”

Harper
recognized contributions that the Chinese community has made, including
building of the CP Railway.

He
said Canada
as it exists today wouldn't be possible without the efforts of the Chinese
community.

“You
are part of our family,” he said.

Harper
formally apologized to Chinese-Canadians for the tax in Parliament on June 22,
calling it a “grave injustice.”

Vancouver's
Community Care and Advancement Association president Johnny Fong, thanked
Harper Tuesday for the government's apology.

“Your
apology at the House of Commons this year has brought tremendous relief to so
many in the community,'' Fong told Harper.

The
prime minister said the government's decision was long overdue.

“Apologizing
for the head tax was simply the right thing to do,” he said.

The
Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality, however, said Tuesday that
Ottawa has been slow to
address the issue.

“He
only addressed point-six per cent of the head tax families — less than one per
cent — of the head tax families that have survivors,” the association's
Sid Tan told The Canadian Press at a protest outside the dinner for Harper.

“What
he has done is rewarded the government for dragging its feet for over 20 years.
Shame on them for that.”

It
is believed there are about 400 surviving head-tax payers or their widows from
an estimated 81,000 immigrants who paid the tax between 1885 and 1923 when the
federal government tried to restrict Chinese immigration.

The
tax, which was set at $50 when it was imposed in 1885, rose to $500 in 1903 —
then the equivalent of two years' wages.

Collection
of the tax ended when the Exclusion Act came into effect in 1923, effectively
barring immigration from China
until it was repealed in 1947.

With
files from The Canadian Press

http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20061011/head_tax_061011/20061011?hub=TopStories

 

PM lauded and protested in Chinatown

Oct, 11 2006 – 12:50 AM

VANCOUVER/CKNW(AM980)
– While Stephen Harper was being praised inside for being the first Prime
Minister in 50 years to address the historical head tax on Chinese immigrants,
protestors outside a dinner with Vancouver 's
Chinese Business community weren't as happy with Harper.

The Head Tax Families Society of Canada was one of 30 groups that supported a
protest outside last night's event.

Meena Wong says Harper's head tax re-dress recognizes fewer than one per cent of
the families who suffered under the financial weight, “There's
approximately 81-thousand who paid the head tax and the Harper Government only
addressed the survivors as well as their spouses which is about 500.”

The group
is lobbying for what they call complete and proper re-dress.

A 99-year
old head tax survivor was among those that presented Harper with a gift last
night, acknowleding his Government's apology in the House of Commons.

http://www.cknw.com/news/news_local.cfm?cat=7428218912&rem=49509&red=80121823aPBIny&wids=410&gi=1&gm=news_local.cfm

 

Chinese head tax redress payments starting soon: PM

Last Updated: Wednesday, October 11, 2006 | 8:30 AM ET

CBC
News

The federal government will begin to redress the
Chinese head tax with payments to survivors within the next few
weeks, Prime Minister Stephen Harper said.

Speaking Tuesday in Vancouver
at a dinner hosted by a Chinese immigrant group, Harper called the tax “a
moral blemish on our country's soul.”

Johnny Fong of the Community Care and Advancement Association speaks after Prime Minister Harper's announcement on the start of Chinese head-tax payments.
Johnny Fong of the Community Care and
Advancement Association speaks after Prime Minister Harper's announcement on
the start of Chinese head-tax payments.

(CBC)

The prime minister formally
apologized to Chinese-Canadians in the House of Commons in June and offered a
symbolic payment of $20,000 to the roughly 400 survivors or their widows.

Those payments will begin in the next few weeks, he said.

“Addressing it directly and honestly has been an
issue we felt strongly about for some time,” said Harper.
“Apologizing for the head tax was simply the right thing to do and it was
long overdue.”

Imposed between 1885 and 1923, the tax ranged from $50 to
$500. It's estimated about 82,000 Chinese paid the fee until the Exclusion Act
came into effect in 1923, effectively banning further immigration from
China
until 1947.

Harper said the redress payment was a token and can't
make up for the suffering caused by the tax.

Johnny Fong, president of Vancouver's Community Care and
Advancement Association, said Chinese-Canadians appreciate the recognition.

“Your apology at the House of Commons to the
affected families has brought tremendous relief to so many in the
community,” he said.

With files from the Canadian
Press

 

http://www.cbc.ca/canada/story/2006/10/11/head-tax.html

Head-tax survivors to get cash soon0

Canadian Press

VANCOUVER ¡ª Symbolic redress payments to Chinese
head tax survivors will begin in the next few weeks, Prime Minister Stephen
Harper says.

It is important that this happen now while some of
those who paid the tax to enter Canada
are still living, Mr. Harper said.

Speaking at a dinner hosted by a Chinese immigrant
group, he called the tax ¡°a moral blemish on our country's soul.¡±

Mr. Harper recognized several contributions of the
Chinese community, including building of the CP Railway.

Related to this article

Latest Comments Comments

The Globe and Mail

He said
Canada as it exists today would not
have been possible without the Chinese community's efforts.

¡°You are part of our family,¡± he said.

Mr. Harper apologized for the tax in Parliament on
June 22.

In doing so, he offered compensation for what he
called ¡°a great injustice.¡±

On Tuesday, Johnny Fong, president of Vancouver's
Community Care and Advancement Association, thanked Mr. Harper for the
government's apology to the Chinese community.

¡°Your apology at the House of Commons this year has
brought tremendous relief to so many in the community,¡± Mr. Fong said.

The Prime Minister responded that the government's
decision wasn't brave.

¡°Apologizing for the head tax was simply the right
thing to do, and it was long overdue,¡± he said.

Mr. Harper also acknowledged that many ancestors of
Chinese Canadians faced large amounts of prejudice and discrimination when they
arrived in Canada .

He said the $20,000 payments are just a token that
cannot make up for the suffering imposed on families who had to scrimp to pay
the tax or who were cut off from their families by the 1923 Exclusion Act,
which effectively banned further immigration from China until 1947.

The Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality,
however, said Tuesday that the government has dragged its feet on the redress
issue.

¡°He only addressed point-six per cent of the head tax
families ¨C less than one per cent ¨C of the head tax families that have
survivors,¡± the association's Sid Tan said at a protest outside the dinner for
Harper.

¡°What he has done is rewarded the government for
dragging its feet for over 20 years. Shame on them for that.¡±

It is believed there are about 400 surviving head-tax
payers or their widows.

They are the remnants of an estimated 81,000
immigrants who paid the tax, which was set at $50 when it was imposed in 1885.

It rose to $500 in 1903 ¨C then the equivalent of two
years' wages.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20061011.wheadtax1011/EmailBNStory/National/home

Reporter
battered

10/11/2006
02:10:00 AM

A Ming Pao reporter was assaulted when he was covering
the rally outside Floata Restaurant last night.

100+ demonstrators from 30+ community groups peacefully showed their
discontent on the streets at Keefer and Columbia
from about 5pm.

Demonstrators were blocking some streets and cars weren't able to go in or
out. Drivers were honking loudly, and demonstrators were yelling using
speakers.

One driver was outraged for being caught in the middle of the traffic. He
suddenly got out of his car, wanting to show his anger.

When he saw the Ming Pao reporter taking pictures, he rushed up and tried to
grab the reporter's camera. The reporter resisted, turning his back to
protect the camera. The man attacked him from the side, and the reporter's
eye glasses flew over and landed on the ground.

The man was taken away quickly. But the reporter suffered abrasion to his eye
and a broken pair of glasses.

Tags: demonstration, , stephen harper, chinese community,
chinese canadian,
vancouver, chinatown, head tax, reporter, demonstration, rally

Subscribe to this feed
Add
to del.icio.us
Add
to Technorati Favorites!
Track
co.mments

0 comments ¡ñ link to this post  

<<–HOME

 






image

Direct
dialogue => monologue

10/11/2006
02:00:00 AM

Stephen Harper's “direct dialogue” dinner with
the Chinese community last night turned out to be a show place for our prime
minister.

Organizer Johnny
Fong (·½¾ýŒW) was reported saying
that
Harper would speak for 20 minutes, then he'd take a few questions from the
floor but stressed Harper wouldn't possibly answer all questions
“because of time constraint”.

However, it turned out to be a completely no answer night.

Fong has forwarded five questions for Harper before his speech. Most of them
related to China-Canada relations, trade and ADS. However, no where in
Harper's speech answered any of Fong's questions, which are seen as questions
of particular concern to local Chinese businesses in general.

Not only that, Harper didn't take any questions from the floor. He did pose
for pictures with as many guests as possible though, asking each table to
come on stage to smile with him in front of a backdrop Harper once used when
he redressed the head tax controversy.

George Chow (Öܾ¼ÈA), city coucillor
and former chair of the Chinese Benevolence Assn, said h
e was surprised that none of
the issues the community wanted to hear about were addressed by Harper.
“Though the atmosphere was good, it wasn't a 'dialogue' per se.”

Fong said he wasn't disappointed that his questions weren't answer.
“Perhaps he didn't have enough time to prepare for some answers.”

But Harper was taking notes while Fong raised the questions, according to
Fong. Fong believed Harper wanted to formulate the answers later.

Fong claimed the dinner a success and it's a good start to have a PM sitting
down, talking with the Chinese community. Fong said he wanted to hold more
community events like this with the PM.

Harper did talk about his gratitude for Chinese Canadian contribution to
building this country. Standing against a backdrop with Chinese words
“apology” written all over, Harper thanked the Chinese community
for welcoming the redress package.

But not all Chinese organizations would agree. Sid Tan (ÖÜÃ÷Ýx)
with the Association of Chinese Canadians for Equality and Solidarity Society
(ACCE
SS)
was among about the 100
demonstrators rallied
outside Floata Restaurant tonight.

Tan said Harper's so-called “redress” only addressed 0.6% of all
head tax collected. “This is a very very small amount.”

Head Tax Families Society of Canada couldn't get an invitation at the end (here).
Tin Yan Wong (üSÌì¶÷) said they first approached the
organizer to express their interest in getting an invitation. However, they
were told they should ask who and who and who and so on, and eventually no
one gave them an invitation. “That's why we are here.”

On the other hand, to the dismay of the media, reporters were ushered into a
separate room after hearing Harper's speech. They were “invited” to
have dinner in that room. But in fact they were told that even if someone
didn't want to eat, he/she still had to stay in the room. Reporters were told
“this is for security reasons.”

Reporters complained that they were like under house arrest, as there were
people guarding the door, preventing any reporter to sneak out.

When the reporters were “released”, they were told they could then
take group photos of Harper smiling with a bunch of guests.

This is the Tories' interpretation of “dialogue”.

Tags: stephen harper, conservative party,
tories, canada, politics, chinese canadian,
chinese community,
vancouver, chinatown, head tax

Subscribe to this feed
Add
to del.icio.us
Add
to Technorati Favorites!
Track
co.mments

0 comments ¡ñ link to this post  

<<–HOME

 






image

Redress
payments to Chinese head tax survivors to begin soon: PM

10/11/2006
01:02:00 AM

From the Canadian Press, October 10, 2006

VANCOUVER
Prime Minister Stephen Harper says symbolic redress payments to Chinese head
tax survivors will begin in the next few weeks.

Harper says it¡¯s important that this happen now while some of those who paid
the tax to enter Canada
are still living.

Speaking at a dinner hosted by a Chinese immigrant group, he called the tax
¡°a moral blemish on our country¡¯s soul.¡±

Harper recognized several contributions of the Chinese community, including
the building of the CP Railway.

He says Canada
as it exists today wouldn¡¯t be possible without the Chinese community¡¯s
efforts.

The Prime Minister also acknowledged that many ancestors of Chinese Canadians
faced large amounts of prejudice and discrimination when they arrived here.

 

http://www.chineseinvancouver.blogspot.com/